There are many areas that might be used to trace the course of Western philosophy. Physical causation – an interesting topic in its own right – is a good example. And what a fascinating story that history is – one we should appreciate in all its roiling complexity, logic, and magnificence. At its heart are two ideas: that a certain event will, under the same circumstances, always and inevitably lead to the same effect; and that every event is the result of a cause. Traditionally this is illustrated with a billiard ball knocking into and causing another billiard ball to move. Of course, we might intervene and stop the second ball moving, or there may be an earthquake that upsets everything. But all things being equal – all relevant factors being unchanged – we think it is not just likely but inevitable that the first ball will cause the second one to move.
The story of human thinking about causation leads from ascribing it to acts of gods, through Aristotle’s view that causation expressed the essence of objects, then the eleventh century Islamic philosopher Al-Ghazali’s assertion that causation is God’s habit of intervening in the world. New ideas arose with the birth of modern science and the responses of rationalist and empiricist philosophers, until, through the puzzles of the quantum world and analytical philosophy’s retreat from metaphysics, the New Essentialists recently went back to the ideas of Aristotle.
Gottfried Leibniz (1646-1716) and Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677) were both determined to demonstrate that every event had a cause. They were both great champions of the principle of sufficient reason – the idea that for everything there must be a cause or set of causes that adequately explains why that thing exists. This implies that nothing could come into existence from nothing (in other words, without a cause). If so, there has to be at least one self-sufficient substance – something that exists necessarily, or as we might say, is the cause of itself. However, they also believed that different substances could not cause an effect one to the other, partly because they were trapped in Aristotle’s logic based on propositions consisting of subjects and their projects with not separate account of relationships. This problem seemed most acute when it came to the interaction of mental and physical substances (that is, the mind and brain), as outlined by Descartes. How could the non-physical mind cause changes in the physical brain?
Spinoza answered that there is only one substance. The entirety of nature, including minds and physical extension, are but aspects of this one substance. And so for him the problem of mind/body interaction dissolved. Leibniz, by contrast invented a bizarre system of ‘pre-established harmony’ between different substances he called monads. The mental and physical realms are like separate pre-set clocks which have been wound up to run in harmony with the other at their creation by God. Therefore, although mental and physical do not interact it appears as though they do, because they continue to run in harmony.
|
Know Your MBA Exams |
|